Major Donor Fundraising - Tools and Strategies for Major Donors

Major Donor Fundraising - Tools and Strategies for Major Donors

When it comes to nonprofit fundraising, nothing tips the scales like a major donor. These whales don’t often make sizeable contributions to charities, so when they do, you’ve really hit it big. This is because major donors, more times than not, don’t just give big in the way of financial donations, they also bring with them a wealth of expertise, strategic insights, and their own well off network of family, friends and business associates, all of which can change the course of your nonprofit forever.

So don’t look at major donors as just a way to pay the bills, if these people are investing into your charity, there’s a good reason. And they want to see a return on their investment! That means these key supporters are willing go the distance and help your organization whenever possible in a myriad of ways. Many also go so far as joining your board of directors or holding fundraising events at their own residences. They’re also often just as passionate about your mission as any other donor, they just have the finances and clout to have a much larger positive impact than many others.

So understanding their importance, how to go about closing them, and what you should be doing after you have landed your substantial donor should be one of the most important strategies in your fundraising arsenal. With a well laid out plan it is possible to attract these large givers and take them through the donor cycle so they become not just beneficiaries for life, but strong supporters, advocates and sometimes even close friends.

Identifying and Approaching Potential Major Donors

When it comes to securing large donors or even foundations, the process is a bit science, art and perhaps even a little luck. Firstly, you’re going to need some hard data on all your donors. From the very beginning of your charity one of the best things you can do is to create a donor database that includes every single detail you can on each donor. Everything from what their favorite activities are, to what other organizations they’re involved in, and all the dates, times and content of the conversations you’ve had with them. The better you can understand any donor before interacting with them, the more leverage you’ll have in persuading them to support your cause.

Another powerful aspect of data driven research is you’re able to create algorithms or use specialized tools that can canvass your data and extract the most likely people on your supporters list that could likely become large donors in order to focus your time more productively. These advanced advanced analytical tools can sift through vast amounts of data to discern patterns and predict potential major donors.

Through a sophisticated process of analyzing the past donation behavior of your supporters, wealth screening results, and engagement levels, your organization can create a shortlist of individuals who have both the means and the potential inclination to give substantially to your charity’s cause. This makes sure that your time and resources are used as efficiently as possible making your fundraising efforts more efficient, cost effective and profitable.

Combine the power of data with the power of your networks and your fundraising efforts can really pick up steam. Research has proven time and time again that personal connections can often unlock doors that data alone cannot. By using the potential of board members, existing donors, and volunteers, organizations can tap into their rich network of friends and other relationships. Furthermore when using people to introduce your cause and mission, their existing personal connections with your charitable organization inherently includes a trust factor that is a powerful motivator for others to become larger donors of your entity.

Once you’ve finally identified potential whales, the next step is to engage with these individuals on a personal level. You’ll need to tailor your communications to each individual, hopefully using all of the other data you have on them so you know which forms of contact they prefer, what touches their heartstrings, and what would make them comfortable enough to offer a substantial gift. The main idea here is you want to make it obvious how much your cause and their values or wishes are aligned so there is no friction when it comes time to write a substantial check.

In addition, leveraging networks for fundraising isn't just about identifying new prospects; it also involves nurturing existing relationships. Getting your major donors or more affluent supporters to host charitable events at their homes or speak at important events on your behalf is a strong way for them to influence their peers into supporting your charity. Again, the personal connections that already exist between these people already associated with your cause and their networks of family and friends create a level of trust that could otherwise take years to build. So use these individuals as effectively as possible.

By including both the newest forms of data driven research and go old fashioned networking, you can dramatically increase your ability to find and land major donors for your cause. And although this process may seem a bit daunting at first, oncce you have a process to identify these individuals and follow up with them on a personal level, you’ll understand the difference these people can make when it comes time to propel your charity forward into the future.

Deep Engagement with Major Donors

Building deep, lasting relationships with major donors is the key to increasing the reach of your organization as quickly as possible. Especially as a smaller nonprofit, just one or two of these affluent individuals can create a huge bump in the effectiveness of your charity. But these individuals want to feel special in return for their contributions. They want to also feel included, heard and sometimes even have a bit of influence over the organization itself in the form of a board position or other leadership role.

By keeping these points in mind when communicating with them, it is easier to find what buttons to push in order to make them feel comfortable and part of the entity as a whole. The more special they feel and the more involved, the longer these special people with stick around and continue to support your charity and its mission. Always think of them as important partners in your mission who require careful and considerate interaction.

Developing Personalized Engagement Plans

When communicating with individuals you’re hoping will at some point begin making significant contributions to your organization, the worst thing you can possibly do is to be sending them standardized materials that have no personal connections to the people receiving them nor any reasons to feel they are anything more than a simple financial transaction.

This is why creating personalized engagement plans are so important to the overall success of landing large donors and keeping them involved for years to come. And although it may not sound all that easy to create a plan for your own charity or foundation, all it takes is a little preparation and understanding the necessary steps that need to be included.

Understanding Donor Motivations

In order to get as specific and personal as possible, you need to understand your potential supporter’s motivations, or what makes them tick. Some are driven by personal experiences, others by the desire to make a societal impact, and yet others by community ties or even the tax benefits that come with donating to a 501(c) organization. It’s your job to find out their motivations and personal preferences using all the information available including having direct conversations with each individual, using donor surveys, and collecting and analyzing behavioral data analysis.

All of this information should be stored in a main donor file that is available to all your staff so when it comes time for them to be contacted, whom ever is responsible for dealing with a particular donoor always has all the facts possible on them so they can know what to speak to them about in order to make that personal connection.

For example, if you know Tom Harris is a likely candidate and you also know he gives large contributions to two other organizations while sitting on the board of one of them, and he also enjoys playing golf each weekend, you know he likes to be involved with charities and is willing to support your cause with more that just funding.

That situation would be a great opportunity to ask him to become more involved with your organization, possibly helping you plan a fundraising event, or asking him if he’d like a personalized tour of your offices so he can see everything from the other side to establish how eager he’s be to become personally involved with your mission. You should also be personally calling on him to invite him to your golf tournament fundraiser as you know he actually enjoys the game.

This sort of specific understanding allows your organization to align it’s appeals and communications directly with the donor’s interests and values, making each interaction more relevant and impactful thereby reducing large amounts of friction for the close.

Tailoring Engagement to Individual Preferences

As we’ve already alluded to above, the more you can tailor each aspect of your communications directly with your prospect, the more successful you’re going to be at getting them to fully commit to supporting your mission and goals. This all takes into consideration customizing the ways in which you interact with each donor based on their preferences for communication as far as personal meetings, emails or even quick phone conversations, the types of events they enjoy go to and getting involved in, and the level of public acknowledgment they are comfortable with.

For example, one person may want highly detailed assessments of what their donation is going to be used for with as much detail as possible, while another person may just want a quick phone call from you quickly explaining what it’ll be used for in large, broad strokes. This can also be the same for a follow up report on what their capital was actually spent on the amount of actual impact it had on the overall problems you’re organization is trying to alleviate.

Still other people may want to have a nice luncheon where they can take their time and talk over the details while at the same time meeting with you personally in order for them to feel more comfortable with your level of commitment to your mission. Or perhaps they enjoy personal interaction with your staff during events when they can allow themselves some free time to be fully immersed rather than be bothered by the business of their everyday lives.

It’s up to you and your team to understand what each individual needs in order to feel hard and appreciated. And everyone is different, so it can take a little time and effort to begin to effectively communicate with each separate individual and learn how to best demonstrate your appreciation for all their support. But these steps are always worth it in the end. After all, it’s a lot different asking for a large $50,000 donation than asking people on Facebook to donate 20 bucks.

Implementing Strategic Communication Tactics

Effective communication isn’t just about the occasional phone call or lunch engagement, it also includes how often you should be speaking with or communicating with each individual as well as the different types of communication channels they respond to best.

Frequency and Modes of Communication

Trying to figure out how often someone wants to hear from you can be a bit tricky. Engage with someone too often and they feel like you’re pestering them, contact them too infrequently and they’ll feel you don’t fully appropriate their commitment. It’s a balance that takes some time to get just right, along with a little intuitive process. So be sure if you’re not contacting these people personally, you’re using someone with the skills to successfully read people’s actions and reactions.

One thing to remember is more often than not many of your big players will be extremely busy people with other things on their minds other than if your charity is functioning properly. They’re often business people, community leaders, or other forms of creators that endure hectic schedules and meetings all day. Again, it’s so important to understand each person as an individual.

Too much communication can overwhelm or annoy donors, while too little can make them feel neglected or out of the loop. Typically, regular updates through emails or newsletters, combined with personalized communications for special occasions or updates on specific projects, strike the right balance.

The mode of communication should also vary based on the donor’s preferences, whether it’s email, physical mail, phone calls, or in-person meetings, each response will need to be gauged in order to know if you’re carrying out your communications in an effective manner. To start you can try multiple channels to see their response. If you’re sending emails that are remaining unopened, yet videos are indeed being watched, you now know their content preference and can create more using that media and form of delivery.

Content Strategy for Effective Major Donor Communications

Creating a content strategy for communicating with your large donors involves understanding your audience at a very deep level, developing tailored content specifically for them, and utilizing a variety of communication methods to foster engagement and trust.

This all starts with developing content that resonates with your audience. This can include content that highlights the tangible results of your donor’s donations by featuring real-life stories of what the impact of your organization's efforts were and how through the gifts bestowed on your organization is what made it all possible. You can even go into more detail and depth by offering them detailed case studies of your impact, and the need for more funding in order to continue offering help and support to those in need.

Or simply collect testimonials directly from the individuals who have benefited from your charity’s commitment to help talking about how your work has changed their lives for the better. You can do the same with interviews or even short films about their stories. These sorts of communications are a fantastic way of not only demonstrating your charity's effectiveness as a solution, but it also humanizes your work and allows your potential supporters to feel and make a deeper connection with those in need.

These sorts of communications should focus on building a narrative over time that aligns with your organization’s ongoing projects and goals. This might include progress updates, behind-the-scenes content related to projects they have supported, and insights into your future plans and the needs of your cause.

All of this should also be created with your donors in mind in ways that are easiest for them to absorb. This can include quick updates through email or quick posts on your social media channels. You can also be taking advantage of video, both long and short form ones. Even images are great ways to convey emotion. Each piece of content should be crafted to not only inform but also inspire and engage, reinforcing the value of their continued support.

One idea that isn’t often discussed is offering virtual meetings, or webinars in order to demonstrate you’re charity’s effectiveness and build your tribe of supporters. These virtual events can include all that we’ve written above and end with a question and answer session to be sure each supporter has all the information they need in order to continue feeling part of the team. These are also great opportunities to do a shout out thanking a major donor for the generous contribution.

Just be sure there is always a feedback mechanism in place. This allows donors to share any thoughts on your organization's direction or the content they have received. Again, webinars are great for this. This way everyone involved feels heard, respected and part of something larger then themselves which is crucial for sustaining long-term relationships. This feedback loop can also provide valuable insights that help refine and optimize your content strategy and gauge how effective your overall content plan actually is.

Fostering Donor Loyalty and Retention

Once you finally start accumulating those individuals responsible for making sizable contributions, the last thing you want to do is to loose their support. This means your commitment to their ongoing loyalty is always of major concern. This involves not just recognizing their contributions but also integrating them into the long-term strategy of your organization through a few different courses of action.

Recognition Programs and Their Impact

Being recognized is always a powerful motivator for many donors to feel part of something and wanting to stick around for the long haul. And luckily there are many ways that you can go about recognizing these people from listing them in annual reports to inviting them to exclusive events or publicly acknowledging their contributions in media or through awards. Even posting simple thank you letters on your website or social media channels can be enough.

But be aware not everyone loves publicity. Some donors want to stay in the background and shy away from the spotlight. They genuinely just want to help and don’t need the recognition others may need. Again, this all comes down to understanding your supporters on an intimate level.

And if for some reason you’re not entirely sure which way to go with a donor, simply ask them. Just tell them how grateful you are for there generous gift and you’d like to let others know how grateful you are, so you’d like to list their name in your upcoming newsletter or some other form of public acknowledgment and ask if that would be alright. These people will give you a straight answer and then just go with their wishes from there.

Regardless of the form it takes, giving recognition where its due is a great way to make donors feel valued and respected, which just further enhances their emotional and psychological commitment to your cause thus keeping them involved that much longer.

Long-term Major Donor Fundraising Strategies for Donor Retention

When it comes to long-term donor retention, you’re going to need to continually engage with your donors in a dialogue about their interests and how these align with the evolving needs and opportunities within your organization. Letting them know about upcoming board vacancies, needed help at different fundraising events, or even volunteer requirements that go out in the field are all opportunities to keep your people engaged and continually feel they are an important part of your charity. It also helps them see the positive impact their donation is having in the real world.

All in all the retention of these key supporters isn’t always about just securing funds, it’s also about building enduring partnerships that benefit both the donors and your organization. By developing personalized engagement plans as part of your major donor fundraising strategies, implementing strategic communication tactics, and fostering loyalty and retention, organizations can create a supportive community of committed donors who are invested in the success of their mission. This approach not only secures necessary resources but also strengthens the overall mission by aligning it closely with the values and aspirations of its most significant supporters.

Innovations in Major Donor Fundraising Technology

Recent advances in technology have drastically changed the way organizations deal with major donor fundraising. Now more than ever nonprofits have been equipping themselves with a wide array of specialized tools that not only streamline the way they connect with their most significant contributors but also deepen their understanding of these donors’ behaviors and preferences. This gives us the opportunity to create interactions that are far more personalized and impactful which in turn makes the entire process far more successful and profitable.

One of the most powerful tools used by many leading nonprofits is PayBee, a platform accessible at https://w.paybee.io/, that has become a standout solution in major donor fundraising. PayBee offers a complete suite of tools that goes far beyond simple donor information management to include rich engagement and tracking capabilities. And since we built our platform from the ground up to be used specifically in the nonprofit sector, we’ve included a host of tools to facilitate interactive donor experiences through an intuitive interface that supports both virtual and in-person events, comprehensive campaigns, and thoughtful donor recognition initiatives.

But even as powerful as PayBee is, there are still a few other specialized tools that can take you game to another level. Advanced CRM systems, personalized engagement platforms, and sophisticated data analytics software for prospect research are revolutionizing donor relationship management in ways that have never been possible before. Luckily seamlessly integrating these technologies into our PayBee platform is as simple as a few clicks.

Specialized Technological Innovations

Now more than ever there is a dizzying array of very specialized tools available to enhance your donor cultivation strategies. These tools are becoming invaluable in order to keep up with the ever increasingly competitive nonprofit sector, and many of these tools are now even a must have just to be able to compete. We’ll go over each tool and why they’re so effective so you can grasp a better understanding of their use and overall effectiveness.

  1. Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems: Tools like Salesforce for Nonprofits, Blackbaud, and NeonCRM are invaluable for managing your donor’s information, keeping track of all donor communications, donations, and other key data. This centralized database lets your staff create personalized communications and helps build stronger relationships with your donors by understanding their interests, giving patterns, and engagement history. When using a CRM, building relationships with major donors is not only easier, but everything you do is filed away and analyzed in order to gain insights on your supporters over time for a more profitable stewardship of individuals.
  2. Data Analytics Platforms: Platforms such as Tableau or Google Analytics provide powerful insights into donor behavior and your fundraising campaign performance. These tools allow you to analyze massive amounts of data to identify trends, segment donors, and optimize your fundraising strategies in seconds. Once you understand which of your campaigns are the most profitable or which donor segments are most engaged and most likely to offer a major gift, it’s much easier for you to tailor your resources on those areas which will give you the most positive outcomes.
  3. Digital Marketing Tools: Tools like HubSpot and Mailchimp help you and your staff create and manage targeted email marketing campaigns, content management, and offer complete automation. These technologies enable your nonprofit to send personalized updates, appeals, and acknowledgments to those making major gifts in a timely manner. The effective use of digital marketing tools enhances the donor engagement process and increases the frequency of donations and can even boost event participation.
  4. Event Management Software: Platforms like PayBee's event management features help in organizing, ticketing, and running all of your fundraising events, including virtual galas and auctions. These tools simplify logistical planning and enable online participation from anywhere in the world with an internet connection which greatly expands your organization’s reach and instantly making it a global player. By making your events more accessible and easier to manage, your charity can attract more participants and increase fundraising success.
  5. Mobile Giving and Text-to-Donate Services: Services like Qgiv and Text-to-Give give donors the ability to make contributions directly from their mobile devices. These types of services are usually limited in their scope, but are great options for low cost donation software.
  6. Planned Giving Software: Tools like Crescendo and Stelter provide resources and management systems for handling bequests, annuities, and other forms of planned giving. They help nonprofits manage and promote legacy giving programs, which can be a major source of long-term financial support. By facilitating easier management and promotion of these programs, nonprofits can secure future funding and build enduring donor relationships.
  7. Donor Research and Wealth Screening Tools: WealthEngine, DonorSearch, and iWave are critical for identifying potential major donors and estimating their giving capacity. These tools provide insights into a donor’s wealth, philanthropic interests, and past giving history, enabling more strategic outreach and personalized engagement. Utilizing these tools can help nonprofits prioritize their efforts and tailor their pitches to match the interests and capacities of potential major donors.

While some of these tools are extremely helpful when it comes to successful major donor fundraising, one thing to always consider is the cost of each tool. Often times it’s more economical to use a bundled tool suite like PayBee that can offer everything your nonprofit needs both right now, and in the future as your organization grows.

Your Major Gifts Program

A major gifts program should be an important part of your nonprofit's gift fundraising strategy as it strategically focuses on securing major gifts from prospects who have the capacity and inclination to make major financial contributions. The idea here is to have a committed team to specifically deal with major donors specifically so they can focus on creating and sustaining deep, long-term relationships with donors who can make a major impact on your organization’s mission.

Understanding the structure and benefits of a major gifts program, along with the role of major gift officers, can help you target these major players more effectively if your organization is large enough to commit the resources necessary to get the job done.

What is a Major Gift Program?

A major gifts program is designed to identify, engage, and steward donors that have the capacity to make major contributions, typically significantly higher than the average donation size specific to your organization. A major gift can come in any form including money, stocks, real estate, or other valuable assets that can assist in your organization’s mission. These types of major donors give in a major way, and often contribute a substantial portion of your fundraising revenue.

The program is structured around personalized relationship-building strategies and is administered by the gifts officer. It focuses on understanding the motivations, interests, and philanthropic goals of your potential major donors and ways of getting them involved with your organization's projects and long-term objectives. This all makes sure your major givers feel their contributions are making a meaningful difference while at the same time allowing your major donors to feel as though they are an important part of your organization.

Why Have a Major Gifts Program?

An effective major gifts program allows your donors to feel their contributions are making a meaningful difference which helps to foster satisfaction and ongoing engagement.

Why Have a Major Gifts Program?

  1. Sustainable Funding: Major giving provide substantial financial contributions that can help stabilize your organization's financial situation. They are especially crucial for supporting large-scale projects, expansions, and endowments, ensuring long-term sustainability and less dependence on smaller, more variable donations.
  2. Efficient Resource Allocation: Focusing on major gifts can be more cost-effective compared to other fundraising strategies. Although cultivating major donors requires upfront time and resources, the return on investment is generally much higher, allowing nonprofits to achieve more with their resources.
  3. Enhanced Donor Relationships: A major gifts program encourages building a deeper major donor cultivation program that allows for closer, more personal relationships with your donors. This major donor stewardship not only increases the likelihood of repeated gifts but also transforms donors into passionate advocates for the organization who may influence others to support the cause.
  4. Strategic Impact: By securing larger sums from fewer donors, organizations can strategically fund initiatives that have a transformative impact on their mission, whether it’s launching new programs, expanding services, or increasing operational capacities.

The Role of a Major Gift Officer

Major gift officers are professionals dedicated to managing relationships with potential and existing major donors. They play a pivotal role in the success of a major gifts program by:

  • Identifying Potential Donors: Using tools and data to identify and qualify high-net-worth individuals who have the capacity and interest in supporting the organization significantly.
  • Building Relationships: Developing and maintaining personal relationships through regular, strategic communications, meetings, and engagements that align with each donor’s interests and values.
  • Making the Ask: Skillfully soliciting major gifts by making personalized, compelling cases for support that resonate with the donor’s philanthropic vision.
  • Stewarding Donors: Ensuring that donors are recognized in meaningful ways, kept informed about the impact of their contributions, and engaged with the organization’s ongoing activities and needs.
  • Coordinating with Leadership: Working closely with the organization’s leadership to align fundraising strategies with overall mission goals and to involve key figures in donor cultivation and stewardship activities.

Having a major gifts program that is run by skilled major gift officers is not just about fundraising—it’s about fostering significant partnerships that can lead to game-changing support for your nonprofit. Creating such a program is a strategic decision that can have a massive impact on your ability to run a grow your organization for years to come. So if you do have the ability and resources to create your own program, this one area can dramatically improve your finances, sometimes overnight!

Wrapping Up

Although it may seem difficult to land and steward major donors, the time and resources it takes is worth the effort for the massive impact they can have on your organization. Careful planning, the use of innovate technologies we’ve gone over, and building a team and creating a major gifts program can all greatly impact your bottom line and significantly advance your nonprofit's goals.


What exactly qualifies as a 'major gift' in nonprofit fundraising? A major gift simply means a gift given that is substantially bigger than the normal charitable contribution your charity normally receives. These types of gifts can often make a major difference in your organization’s ability to reach its goals and continue operations.

What’s the best way to show appreciation to major donors? Recognition should be tailored to the donor’s preferences. Options include public acknowledgment, private thank you notes, personalized gifts, or exclusive opportunities to see the impact of their support firsthand.

How can I ensure the sustainability of my major gifts program? Continuously nurture donor relationships, regularly assess and refine your strategies, and stay abreast of best practices in donor engagement and recognition. Building a strong, ongoing dialogue with your donors ensures they remain connected and committed to your cause.

Start Fundraising

I am a...

Looking for...

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Nonprofit Fundraising
Nonprofit Tips
Bill Allen

Bill Allen is an expat that has been travelling the world for the past 25 years. He received his MA in writing in New York too long ago to remember, but has been writing on all sorts of subjects far varied publications ever since. When he isn't writing he enjoys meditating and working on his own website, UpscaleDrinks.com. Feel free to connect with him any time.

Latest Articles