Unveiling Classy Hidden Fees and Charges: Understanding the True Price and Cost

When it comes to focusing on doing good and rallying communities, fundraiser events embody hope, unity, and progress. These events provide a way to gather funds for important causes and act as drivers for social change and empowerment.

In today's digital age, where connectivity and convenience take center stage, the significance of fundraising events has only intensified. This is further boosted by innovative tools like the Classy and Paybee nonprofit fundraising events platforms. We'll discuss Classy's features and costs, drawing a side-by-side comparison with Paybee and its charging fees.

Introduction to Classy's Platform and Pricing Fee

Classy, a fundraising platform designed to integrate with WordPress seamlessly, is tailor-made for nonprofits and individuals who run and manage online fundraising campaigns. Being part of the GoFundMe family, Classy equips users with essential tools for peer-to-peer fundraising, event management, and effective donor engagement.

Its robustness extends to its smooth integration with various third-party platforms, including Paypal, Salesforce, Facebook, Mailchimp, Google Analytics, Amply, Charity Auctions Today, and more. Classy ensures user support through various channels, including FAQs, email/help desk, phone support, chat, and more.

Classy offers tailored pricing plans, and you'll need to provide the necessary information to obtain the pricing details. They have a professional plan available at $299 per month, which includes 4% transaction fees as part of the overall pricing. The platform also applies a 2.2% platform fee and a potential payment processor fee of up to 3.2%.

Understanding Fundraising Platform Fees 

Processing payments for nonprofit donations involves more than meets the eye. Beyond the seamless act of making online contributions lies a landscape of charging fees. Let's delve into the intricacies of fundraising platform fees, examining the costs associated with payment processing, platform usage, and the potential pitfalls of hidden charges.

Costs for Processing Payments

Payment processing fees are the charges merchants face when handling credit card and online payments from customers. Simply put, nonprofits accepting online payments incur fees for processing donations through a payment processor. For instance, Stripe's debit and credit payment processing fee is 2.2%, along with an additional $0.30 for non-American Express transactions. Different payment methods, like ACH, AMEX, or Apple Pay, may carry distinct fees. It's essential to note that the choice of payment method can significantly impact the total fees paid by a nonprofit, as each method has cost implications.

Platform Expenses

Apart from payment processing fees, nonprofits may also encounter platform fees linked to their chosen solution. This fee covers the use of fundraising software and can be structured in various ways:

• Flat Fee: This involves paying a fixed amount for using the platform, regardless of the funds raised. While it offers cost predictability, it may pose a challenge if the online fundraising amount could be higher.
• Variable Fee: Calculated as a percentage of online donations, this model allows donors to offset the fee. This provides flexibility, with donors potentially covering a significant portion of the processing fees.
• Tipping: Nonprofits may opt for a tipping model, giving up a flat or variable fee to encourage donors to tip the software vendor. However, this approach may result in higher costs, lack of tax deductibility, and potential confusion for donors.

Hidden Charges and Junk Fees

Some payment vendors may seem to offer low credit card rates initially, but nonprofits need to be wary of hidden charges and junk fees that can impact the final donation amount. These hidden costs include:

• Chargebacks and Refunds: Charges imposed by software vendors and payment processors for handling reversed donations.
• Card Updating Expenses: Fees for updating credit cards automatically upon expiration, with potential costs per card.
• Fraud Monitoring: Charges associated with fraud-monitoring tools on leading platforms.
• Payment-Type Rates: Elevated rates for payment methods like bank transfers or digital wallet options.
• Amex® Rate: Additional processing fees linked to specific payment types, such as American Express.
• Monthly Fees: Subscription or service fees and monthly PCI compliance fees can accumulate over time and impact the nonprofit's financial health.

CFPB Involvement

In the U.S., the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) keeps a close eye on and sets rules for financial transactions to safeguard consumers and keep things transparent. The CFPB is key in stopping unfair and tricky practices, such as hidden fees and extra charges, in the financial sector- nonprofits using fundraising platforms should know about the CFPB's guidelines and rules to stay in line and shield their donors from surprise costs.

Classy vs. Paybee Fees 

When comparing the fees of Classy and Paybee, it's clear that Paybee emerges as a more transparent and cost-effective fundraising platform. Paybee sticks to simple 2% transaction fees for all types of events, whether online donations, virtual events, or in-person/hybrid events- additionally, Paybee has structured its pricing plan to cater to a broad range of consumers, emphasizing the delivery of accessibility and flexibility. 

Paybee offers a complimentary fundraising tier, allowing organizations to get started without immediate financial commitments. Paybee's upgraded suite comes with a reasonable fee structure of $20 per month, with bi-annual billing for those looking to unlock advanced features. This ensures that even smaller to mid-sized nonprofits can tap into a feature-rich fundraising solution without straining their campaign budget. Regarding virtual events, Paybee offers a package priced at $399, allowing unlimited access over two years. 

This cost-effective approach emphasizes Paybee's dedication to providing accessible and flexible solutions for nonprofits across different event formats. In addition to this, there is a 2% charge on electronic transactions associated with these virtual events. Similarly, Paybee extends its support to in-person and hybrid events with an attractive pricing model amount of $599, offering unlimited event access for two years. 

Consistent with the virtual events package, there is a 2% amount charge on all electronic transactions for in-person and hybrid events. This transparent and inclusive pricing structure underscores Paybee's commitment to affordability and flexibility across various fundraising event formats.

In contrast, the comparison reveals a potential risk with Classy, as specific subscription and transaction fees are not readily available on their website. This lack of transparent pricing could pose challenges for consumers concerned about complex pricing structures or hidden fees, introducing an element of uncertainty and potential financial ambiguity when it comes to fundraising campaigns.

In contrast to Paybee's transparency and affordability, Classy's professional plan is available at $299 per month, including a 4% transaction fee as part of the overall pricing. Classy also applies a 2.2% platform fee and a potential payment processor fee of up to 3.2%, adding layers of complexity to its pricing model. 

Paybee's commitment to simplicity, affordability, and donor-friendly features positions it as a compelling choice for organizations with varying budgets and fundraising objectives, highlighting a notable distinction from Classy's tailored but potentially more intricate pricing approach.

How to Avoid Hidden Consumer Fees 

Staying alert for hidden costs behind the scenes is important when dealing with fundraising platforms. While it may not be illegal to keep expenses undisclosed and make it challenging for a consumer to determine the actual costs, it's a questionable practice. Consider these important factors when selecting fundraising software for your nonprofit, whether it be Classy, Paybee, or any other fundraising platform:

Hidden Monthly Consumer Fees

Some fundraising software providers use a tactic to flaunt an attractive annual fee upfront, often less than the monthly price. This can give you a misleading impression of the overall cost. A closer look at the pricing details might reveal a completely higher monthly fee than you first thought.

Dynamic Price Trick

Companies that use dynamic or flexible pricing can tweak prices for each customer individually. Even though they might pitch it as getting the best deal for you, it could end up as price discrimination. Asking for a quote or going for contact-based pricing may need more transparency, making it easier to grasp the extra costs involved.

Usage-Based Consumer Pricing Complications

The usage-based or contact-based pricing model ties the costs to how much you use the fundraising software, like the number of users linked to your account. This approach can cloud monthly or yearly spending costs, a financial headache for most non-profits.

Concealed Extra Costs

Some fundraising software vendors prefer to keep fees or conditions related to their services in the shadows. For instance, processing costs seem reasonable at 1.5%, but digging deeper reveals that this rate applies only if your supporters chip in. Additional hidden costs include training, startup, and support expenses.

Tricky Freemium Consumer Models

While the freemium model, offering free access with paid upgrades, can be legit, some platforms offer seemingly free services only to charge for essential functions later on. It's crucial to scrutinize what features are part of the free version and which come with additional costs.

Comparison Essentials

When comparing crowdfunding platforms, make sure you have a clear picture of what's included and what counts as an extra expense. This thorough evaluation will empower your non-profit to make a savvy decision, avoiding potential pitfalls and ensuring a clear financial commitment.

Questions to Ask Nonprofit Fundraising Providers for Uncovering Potential Hidden Fees and Prices

To uncover and avoid any hidden fees, it's crucial to ask the right questions when dealing with fundraising platform providers. Here are some inquiries to consider:

Clarity on Pricing

• Can you break down all the costs linked to your fundraising platform?
• Are there any extra fees that may not be explicitly mentioned in the pricing details?

Monthly versus Annual Fees

• Do you provide options for monthly and annual payments, and are there any cost distinctions between them
• Are there undisclosed fees tied to opting for an annual payment plan?

Understanding Dynamic Pricing

• How does your pricing model function, and is it subject to dynamic adjustments based on usage?
• Please clarify if there are varying prices for the same services and the rationale behind such distinctions.

Usage-Based Pricing

• Does your pricing hinge on the actual utilization of the fundraising software, like the number of users or donations processed?
• Is there transparency regarding the calculation of charges tied to usage?

Additional Costs and Conditions

• Beyond the prominently displayed fees, are there other potential costs, conditions, or limitations that users should be mindful of?
• Can you provide details on any concealed processing, training, start-up, or support charges?

Freemium Model Clarification

• If you offer a freemium model, which features come with the free version, and which ones are deemed premium or necessitate payment?
• Are there essential functions that users might assume are free but, in reality, incur charges that they need to pay for?

Contractual Transparency

• How transparent is the contract concerning fees, and are there any clauses that could lead to additional costs to pay in the future?
• Can you share examples of scenarios where users might unexpectedly face charges they need to pay?

Asking these questions will aid in obtaining a clearer understanding of the overall cost structure and identifying any potential hidden fees linked to the fundraising platform.

Other Things to Consider

In addition to understanding hidden fees and extra charges, there are several other crucial factors for nonprofits to keep in mind when choosing a fundraising platform:

Approved Rates vs. Published Rates

Regarding payment processing vendors like Stripe offering lower nonprofit rates, remember that these rates often need nonprofits to apply for approval. This ensures that you pay the agreed-upon nonprofit rate after going through the application process.

Donor-Covered Fees

Knowing what portion of your donors covers processing fees is important to determine your overall costs. In the industry, it's commonly seen that 70% or more of donors take care of these fees. For example, if your organization raises $150,000, resulting in a $1,500 payment processing fee, and your donors choose to cover 70% ($1050), your organization would need to handle the remaining $450 in processing fees not covered by donors.

Is Free Really 'Free'?

Even though some vendors claim their tools are free for nonprofits, these tools often rely on donor tipping to cover the software or fundraising platform costs. As mentioned earlier, these tips usually default to 12%, and this percentage can add up over time. While nonprofits might not be directly paying for these, donors contribute to a for-profit company instead of directly supporting the nonprofit.

Ensuring Security

There's a genuine concern about authentication attacks, especially with fraudulent card testing attacks. In these situations, fraud actors get hold of stolen card credentials and submit numerous card-not-present (CNP) transaction authorization requests on a donation form. If your payment processor doesn't cover declined transactions' costs due to such attacks, you could be held accountable for significant financial losses.

FAQs: People Also Ask 

What are the most common hidden fees in fundraising platforms?

Hidden charging fees in fundraising platforms can vary but may include undisclosed monthly charges, processing fees for specific payment methods, and additional costs such as chargebacks, card updating, and fraud monitoring.

How does Classy handle transaction fees?

Classy applies a 4% transaction fee as part of its professional plan, along with a 2.2% platform fee and a potential payment processor fee of up to 3.2%. The platform's pricing model may involve multiple layers of charging fees, which can impact the overall cost for users.

Can hidden fees be negotiated away with platforms like Classy or other vendors?

Negotiation possibilities for hidden fees with Classy or other similar vendors may vary. It's recommended to inquire directly with the platform about negotiating charging fees and obtaining a clear understanding of the terms and conditions.

Does the White House have a say in determining fees for nonprofit fundraising platforms?

The White House doesn't directly control the fees for nonprofit fundraising platforms. However, federal agencies like the FTC may have a role in overseeing fair business practices within the industry.

What steps has the Biden administration taken regarding hidden fees in online fundraising?

There needs to be more specific information about actions by the Biden administration concerning hidden fees in online fundraising. Nonprofits should keep themselves updated on policy changes that might affect fundraising practices.

How can nonprofits effectively convey fee-related information to donors through marketing strategies? 

Nonprofits can adopt transparent marketing practices, including clearly communicating fee structures, offering breakdowns of costs, and emphasizing initiatives to reduce hidden fees in fundraising campaigns.

What should nonprofits look for in the fine print when choosing a fundraising platform?

Nonprofits should carefully review the fine print for details on all costs associated with the fundraising platform. This includes understanding monthly and annual fees, dynamic pricing models, usage-based charges, and any additional hidden costs related to processing, training, start-up, or support.

Are there specific rules from the FTC about hidden fees in fundraising platforms?

The FTC actively monitors various business practices associated with fundraising platforms. Nonprofits should stay informed about FTC guidelines to ensure compliance with regulations and uphold transparency in their fundraising efforts.

Choosing the Right Fundraising Platform: Paybee's Transparency Stands Out

As demonstrated in the comparison between Classy and Paybee, the transparency and affordability offered by Paybee presents a compelling choice for nonprofit organizations with diverse budgets and fundraising objectives. Understanding the multifaceted nature of fees, including payment processing, platform usage, and potential hidden charges, is crucial for nonprofits seeking financial clarity.

The engagement with fundraising platform providers should involve asking specific questions, as outlined, to unveil any hidden fees and ensure a clear understanding of the overall cost structure. The commitment to transparency and simplicity exhibited by Paybee sets a standard for accessible and flexible solutions across various fundraising event formats.

Conversely, the potential risk associated with Classy's less transparent pricing model emphasizes the importance of due diligence. To avoid financial ambiguity and unexpected costs, nonprofits should carefully go through the fine print, consider donor-covered fees, and be cautious of seemingly 'free' offerings that may rely on donor tipping.

‍